Homeschooled Mom

Homeschooled as a kid. Homeschooling my kids.

II.26 The Second Reader: Curriculum Corner

Homeschool Spelling Curriculum: Which Approach Fits

A homeschool spelling curriculum comparison by approach: rule-based, visual, word-family, audio and dictation programs, and how to match one to your child.

By Bethany Ellison

Homeschool Spelling Curriculum: Which Approach Fits

The best homeschool spelling curriculum is the one whose approach fits how your child learns. Spelling programs split into five approaches: rule-based programs that teach sounds and rules explicitly (All About Spelling), visual programs built on copywork and letter patterns (Spelling You See), word-family sequences that change one sound at a time (Sequential Spelling), audio programs a child works through alone (Phonetic Zoo), and dictation from real passages (the Charlotte Mason route). Pick the approach first, then the program. Most families start a spelling program around second grade, once phonics is secure.

We use All About Spelling with our eight- and six-year-old, so the rule-based section below is lived. The others are described from their publishers’ own pages, loaded on 2026-11-19. Where spelling fits among the other parts of language arts is in our homeschool language arts curriculum guide. This page compares spelling programs only.

The five approaches at a glance

ApproachExample programHow a lesson worksParent’s roleSuits a child who…
Rule-based, multisensoryAll About SpellingLearn a sound or rule, build words with tiles, then dictationTeaches every lesson from a scriptWants to know why a word is spelled that way
Visual, pattern-basedSpelling You SeeRead a passage, mark letter patterns, copy, then dictationShort daily guidanceRemembers what words look like
Word familiesSequential SpellingSpell a growing family of words (age, cage, page…) and checkLight, or none in the online versionGets bored by rules and likes quick wins
Audio, self-pacedPhonetic ZooListen to words and jingles, spell, self-checkPlacement and occasional checksWorks well alone and learns by ear
Dictation from passagesSimply Charlotte Mason’s Using Language WellStudy a passage, then write it from dictationReads the dictationAlready reads widely

None of these is a grade-level program in the usual sense. Several say so directly, and all of them use a placement test rather than a grade.

Rule-based: All About Spelling

All About Spelling is the program we use. Its publisher calls it a “seven-level” program that teaches “using the Orton-Gillingham approach,” and describes it as “scripted, open-and-go.” In practice that means you read a short script, your child builds words with letter tiles, and the lesson ends with dictated words, phrases and sentences that use the new sound or rule.

Three things about it matter when you compare it with the others:

  • It’s mastery-based, not grade-based. The publisher says “most students start in Level 1 since this is a mastery-based program, not a grade-level program.” That includes older children. A strong nine-year-old may move through the early levels quickly, but still starts there.
  • Review is built in. Each child has their own review cards, so words they miss come back and words they know stop appearing.
  • It’s a short lesson. The publisher’s guide says “as a general rule, we recommend spending 20 minutes per day on spelling,” adjusted for the child’s attention span. That matches our experience. Some days are ten minutes.

You need the teacher’s manual for the level, a student packet such as Level 1’s, and the letter tiles. It suits a child who likes knowing the rule, and a parent who is happy to teach it. It asks for your full attention for every lesson, and for a child who already spells well, the early levels can feel slow.

Our second grade homeschool curriculum picks explain how we added it once phonics was nearly done.

Visual: Spelling You See

Spelling You See, from Demme Learning, starts from the opposite idea. Its home page promises “No spelling tests! No memorizing word lists!” and says “an adept speller is a visual speller.” Lessons are short and daily, and each level combines “speaking and listening, reading, letter pattern recognition, copywork and dictation.” Your child reads a short passage, looks for and marks its letter patterns, copies it, and later writes it from dictation.

There are seven levels, “starting with one for beginning readers who are learning letter names and sounds,” with names rather than grades: Listen and Write, Jack and Jill, Wild Tales, Americana, American Spirit, Ancient Achievements and Modern Milestones. Placement is “skills-based, not grade-based.” Each level is a set of student workbooks, like the Jack and Jill student workbooks, plus an instructor’s handbook.

It suits a child who reads a lot and remembers how words look, and a parent who wants short lessons with little preparation. It can frustrate a child who keeps asking why, because it deliberately doesn’t teach rules.

Word families: Sequential Spelling

Sequential Spelling teaches whole families of words that share a pattern, so a child spells age, then cage, page, stage and engage, adding a little each time. Its online version describes the method as “inductive, not deductive”: children “discover the patterns themselves through practice” with “no abstract rules to memorise.”

The online version, Sequential Spelling Online, has “5 levels” with “180 lessons each” and “up to 25 words per day.” Each word is played aloud, the student types it, and gets immediate feedback. Missed words return for review in later lessons, and the parent can see every score. On 2026-11-19 its home page offered a free five-day trial with no credit card. The printed books are still sold too, with a teacher’s guide for Level 1.

It suits a child who dislikes rules and enjoys a quick daily list, and a parent who wants spelling to run without them. It’s less suited to a child who needs to understand a rule before they believe it.

Audio: Phonetic Zoo

IEW’s Phonetic Zoo is the most independent of the five. Its publisher describes it as a “phonics-based program” that “uses auditory input,” and says “the audio format allows students to work independently much of the time.” Your child listens to the lesson, spells the words, then checks them against the recording. The starter set includes lesson cards with “all three levels of spelling words and jingles,” and “Personal Spelling Cards to keep track of your student’s typical misspellings.”

IEW lists it for grades 3 to 8 and gives a placement test to choose the starting level. It suits an older child who learns well by ear and likes working alone. It’s less suited to a young child who still needs an adult beside them, or a child who doesn’t listen carefully without someone checking.

Dictation: the Charlotte Mason route

The fifth approach doesn’t use word lists at all. A child studies a passage from a good book, notices the hard words, and then writes the whole passage from dictation.

Simply Charlotte Mason’s Using Language Well is the packaged version. Its second edition combines the older Spelling Wisdom books with grammar. In Book 1, which it pitches at a third-grade level, your child “will transcribe the lesson passage to practice handwriting, then write some words from memory.” In Books 2 to 6, spelling is taught “with prepared dictation,” using “real sentences instead of word lists.”

You can also do this without buying anything. Choose a sentence or two from your read-aloud, let your child study it, then dictate it. Copywork and dictation as a method are explained in teaching writing at home.

It suits a child who already reads a lot, and a family that likes literature-based lessons. It’s less suited to a struggling speller, who usually needs the sounds and patterns taught explicitly first.

How to choose

  1. Check that reading is secure first. Spelling is harder than reading. If your child still sounds out simple words, finish phonics before adding spelling. Our guide to teaching your child to read at home covers that sequence.
  2. Watch how your child spells a word they don’t know. If they sound it out and get it phonetically close, a rule-based program builds on that. If they write it and say “that doesn’t look right,” a visual program will make sense to them.
  3. Be honest about your time. All About Spelling needs you for the whole lesson. Spelling You See needs you for a few minutes. Sequential Spelling Online and Phonetic Zoo need you mostly for checking.
  4. Use the placement test, then start lower if in doubt. An easy first week does no harm. Starting too high undermines a child’s confidence.
  5. Give it a term before switching. Most of these programs build on themselves. Change if it’s clearly not working, but not after one bad week.

One more thing: a child who keeps struggling with spelling despite a good program and steady practice is worth mentioning to your pediatrician, since persistent difficulty can sometimes point to a learning difference worth checking.

FAQ: homeschool spelling curriculum

When should a homeschooler start a spelling curriculum?

Usually around second grade, once phonics is secure. Before then, spelling practice is mostly part of learning to read.

Is All About Spelling good for older children?

Its publisher says most students start at Level 1, including older ones, because it’s mastery-based. Older children often move through the first levels quickly.

Which spelling curriculum needs the least parent time?

Sequential Spelling Online and Phonetic Zoo, because the student hears the words and checks them without the parent reading them out.

Do you need a spelling curriculum at all?

Not always. Strong readers often learn to spell well from copywork and dictation from good books. A child who struggles usually needs a structured program.

How long should a spelling lesson be?

Short. All About Spelling’s publisher suggests about 20 minutes a day, adjusted for the child, and Spelling You See is built around short daily activities.

Shelved in The Second Reader: Curriculum Corner

Bethany Ellison, Homeschooled Mom author

About the author

Bethany Ellison

I’m Bethany — homeschooled K–12 in rural Wisconsin back when the jean-jumper jokes were aimed at my actual family, and now homeschooling my own three (8, 6, and a 2-year-old who still naps, which is why anything gets done). In between I went to a state university and spent years as a library programs coordinator, so I’ve seen this from the student’s chair, the teacher’s chair, and the story-time carpet. My husband teaches public school, which keeps this site permanently un-preachy. Curricula are tools, not tribes — we’ve already run this experiment once, and I remember what stuck.

More about Bethany →