Homeschooled Mom

Homeschooled as a kid. Homeschooling my kids.

II.20 The Second Reader: Curriculum Corner

Homeschool Writing Curriculum: Programs Compared by Age

A homeschool writing curriculum comparison by age: what young writers, middle-grade writers and teens need, and how WriteShop, IEW and the others differ.

By Bethany Ellison

Homeschool Writing Curriculum: Programs Compared by Age

The right homeschool writing curriculum depends mostly on your child’s age and on how much you want to teach yourself. Before about age eight, most children don’t need a writing program at all: copywork, dictation and narration do the job, or a gentle parent-led program packages them. From about eight to thirteen, a structured program earns its place, and the main choice is between imitating models (IEW), learning by genre (WriteShop) and the classical writing forms (Writing & Rhetoric). Teens need essays, revision and research, and video-led courses help most here.

We used Writing With Ease through the early years and are now looking at what comes next for our eight-year-old, so the young end of this comparison is lived and the rest is chosen from published specs. The method underneath all of it, from copywork to the first paragraph, is in teaching writing at home. This page compares the programs.

The programs at a glance

ProgramAges or grades, as publishedFormatApproachParent’s role
Writing With EaseEarly elementary, by levelWorkbook + scripted lessonsCopywork, dictation, narrationTeaches every lesson
WriteShop PrimaryAges 5-8Parent-guided activitiesGames, crafts, picture booksTeaches every lesson
WriteShop JuniorAges 8-13Activity-based lessonsGenre, editing, grammarTeaches, then edits with the child
WriteShop I & IIAges 12-17Incremental lessonsDescriptive, informative, narrative writing; self-editingGuides and grades
IEW Structure and Style for StudentsLevel A grades 3-5, B 6-8, C 9+24-week video courseKey-word outlines from source textsWatches progress, gives feedback
Writing & RhetoricFrom grades 3 or 4, sold by gradeOne-semester booksClassical forms (Fable, Narrative…)Teaches from the book
Writing With SkillMiddle gradesWorkbook + instructor textContinues Writing With EaseGuides and checks
Essentials in WritingK-12Video lessonsStep-by-step, modeled by teachersLight; lessons teach the student

Ages and formats come from each publisher’s own pages, loaded on 2026-11-15.

Ages 5 to 8: don’t buy too much

A young child’s writing is limited by their hands and their spelling, not their ideas. That’s why the best early programs separate the two: the child dictates or narrates, and the parent writes or the child copies.

Writing With Ease is the one we used, and it’s the copywork-dictation-narration sequence in workbook form. Lessons are short and scripted, drawn from children’s literature. It’s plain and it works. We used Level 3 for third grade, as described in our third grade homeschool curriculum picks.

WriteShop Primary suits a child who wants more play. Its publisher says it introduces “beginning writing skills to your 5-8 year old student through games, crafts, picture books, and one-on-one teaching time,” as a “parent-guided writing curriculum with daily, easy-to-implement activities.”

Brave Writer is the third name you’ll hear for this age. It’s built more around a family rhythm than a lesson sequence, and we describe it in our teaching-writing guide. Look at its samples alongside the others before choosing.

You can also skip a program completely at this age. Copywork from a good book, a dictated sentence a day and spoken narration after read-alouds cost nothing and teach the same skills.

Ages 8 to 13: the years a program earns its place

This is when children move from sentences to paragraphs, and then from paragraphs to multi-paragraph pieces. Most parents want a structured sequence here, and the three main programs differ in how they teach.

IEW, Structure and Style for Students. The Institute for Excellence in Writing course is a “24-week writing journey” led on video by Andrew Pudewa, with Level A for 3rd to 5th grade and Level B for 6th to 8th. Its method starts from a source text: the student makes a key-word outline of it and then writes their own rough and final drafts from the outline. It suits a child who freezes at a blank page, because there’s always a model to work from. It can frustrate a child who already has a lot to say and wants to choose their own subject from the start.

WriteShop Junior. For ages 8 to 13, it “introduces students … to genre while teaching important writing, editing, and grammar skills,” using pre-writing activities and skill builders. It suits a child who needs writing to feel less like a workbook. It asks more of the parent than a video course, because the activities are done together.

Writing & Rhetoric. Classical Academic Press’s series follows the classical writing exercises in order. Book 1: Fable is “a one-semester course for grades 3 or 4 and up,” and the publisher sells later books by grade into middle school. It suits a family that likes a classical sequence and reading strong models together. It’s less suited to a child who wants to choose their own topics.

Writing With Skill. The middle-grade follow-on to Writing With Ease, in the same Complete Writer series. Level 1 comes as a student workbook and a separate instructor text. It suits a family that liked Writing With Ease and wants the same voice and structure to continue.

How we’d decide among these: if your child stalls before writing anything, IEW. If they write but hate it, WriteShop. If you want a classical sequence and enjoy teaching it, Writing & Rhetoric. If Writing With Ease worked, try Writing With Skill first. In sixth grade, writing turns into multi-paragraph pieces, and the sixth grade homeschool curriculum picks page shows how writing fits into that year’s other work.

Ages 12 to 17: essays, revision and research

Teen writing needs a thesis, a structure the reader can follow, real revision and, by high school, research with sources. It also needs someone other than the writer to read it critically, and that’s where many parents feel least confident.

WriteShop I & II gives “12-17 year old students … a solid foundation in descriptive, informative, and narrative writing,” with self-editing built in, and assignments that include “creative, expository, narrative, and persuasive” writing.

IEW Level C is the “9th+ grade” level of the same video course, so a teen who started IEW younger can continue it.

Essentials in Writing is the most hands-off for the parent. It describes itself as a “comprehensive K-12 homeschool writing and literature curriculum” in which “lessons are expertly modeled by certified educators,” and says its lessons teach “directly to the student.” It also offers a scoring service if you want someone else to grade the essays.

At this age, outside feedback is worth paying for if you can. That might be a co-op writing class, an online course or a scoring service. A teen often takes a comment more seriously from someone who isn’t their parent.

How to choose

  1. Start from the child’s problem, not the program. A child who can’t start needs models (IEW). A child who won’t start needs warmth and variety (WriteShop, Brave Writer). A child who writes freely needs structure and editing (Writing & Rhetoric, WriteShop I & II).
  2. Be honest about your time. Parent-led programs need you there for every lesson. Video courses need you for feedback only.
  3. Use the samples and placement tools. WriteShop has a placement quiz, Essentials in Writing a placement tool, and IEW sample lessons. A week of samples tells you more than any comparison.
  4. Don’t change programs every year. Most of these build a sequence. Switching loses more than it gains unless the current one clearly isn’t working.

FAQ: homeschool writing curriculum

At what age should a homeschooler start a writing curriculum?

Most children don’t need one before about eight. Copywork, dictation and narration cover the early years; a structured program helps once a child is writing paragraphs.

What is the easiest homeschool writing curriculum for the parent?

A video course such as Essentials in Writing or IEW’s Structure and Style for Students, where the lessons teach the student and the parent mainly gives feedback.

Is IEW good for reluctant writers?

Often, especially for children who freeze at a blank page, because every assignment starts from a source text and an outline. Children who already write freely sometimes find the source-text structure restrictive.

Can I teach writing without a curriculum?

Yes, especially in the early years. You need a sequence (copywork, dictation, narration, then paragraphs), regular practice and honest feedback.

What writing curriculum works for high school?

WriteShop I & II, IEW Level C and Essentials in Writing all reach high school. Add outside feedback on essays if you can.

Shelved in The Second Reader: Curriculum Corner

Bethany Ellison, Homeschooled Mom author

About the author

Bethany Ellison

I’m Bethany — homeschooled K–12 in rural Wisconsin back when the jean-jumper jokes were aimed at my actual family, and now homeschooling my own three (8, 6, and a 2-year-old who still naps, which is why anything gets done). In between I went to a state university and spent years as a library programs coordinator, so I’ve seen this from the student’s chair, the teacher’s chair, and the story-time carpet. My husband teaches public school, which keeps this site permanently un-preachy. Curricula are tools, not tribes — we’ve already run this experiment once, and I remember what stuck.

More about Bethany →